How much are McCoy cookie jars worth?
The McCoy Mammy jar, also known as the Aunt Jemima cookie jar, is another example of one that is rare. Even in damaged condition, one of these sold for almost $200. Others, like the adorable but much more common strawberry cookie jar or honey bear, sell for under $100 in good condition because they are easier to find.
What was the first McCoy cookie jar?
The original “Mammy” cookie jar, which was also known as the Aunt Jemima-style cookie jar, is arguably the most popular. The first McCoy cookie jar design, the “Mammy” is also one of the most valuable cookie jars in the secondary market today, valued at several hundred dollars.
What kind of Cookie Jar does McCoy Pottery make?
The jar is green, but when looking at the mark and paper tag, the factory called it slate blue. McCoy Pottery only made two Black mammy cookie jars. Both jars are widely reproduced which has caused values to come down quite a bit over the last few years. A jar with good cold paint is hard to find.
How much is a McCoy Gleep Cookie Jar worth?
A very rare McCoy Gleep cookie jar in good condition sold for $2,500 in early 2020. This goofy looking character jar was missing a little paint in one spot, but this did not detract significantly from the value. Instead of being a more common character jar, this rare example was in the shape of an acorn with oak leaves.
When did the McCoy lovebirds Cookie Jar come out?
McCoy Lovebirds Cookie Jar might also be called the McCoy Penguin jar. The jar was produced in white with cold paint decorating, also was produced in a special black glaze, but only two or three of these black jars are known. Produced in 1942 Mark: McCoy (same as this mark)
Which is the most collectible Cookie Jar on the market?
With their adorable shapes, vintage McCoy cookie jars are a great collector’s item. According to Collectors Weekly, the cookie jars made by McCoy Pottery are among the most collectible on the market due to their enduring charm.
What makes a McCoy Cookie Jar so valuable?
As with any antique, the most valuable vintage McCoy cookie jars are those in excellent condition. Those with cracks, chips, crazing, staining, and other damage will not fetch as much at auction. Additionally, details should be crisp. The glaze should be shiny and in good condition, and painted elements should be sharp.
A very rare McCoy Gleep cookie jar in good condition sold for $2,500 in early 2020. This goofy looking character jar was missing a little paint in one spot, but this did not detract significantly from the value. Instead of being a more common character jar, this rare example was in the shape of an acorn with oak leaves.
With their adorable shapes, vintage McCoy cookie jars are a great collector’s item. According to Collectors Weekly, the cookie jars made by McCoy Pottery are among the most collectible on the market due to their enduring charm.
Who was the first maker of cookie jars?
McCoy Cookie Jars: McCoy was one of the most prolific makers of cookie jars and is considered one of the giants of the industry. It started producing jars in the 1930s. It is claimed that the first figural jar was the mammy with cauliflowers — a jar that is very valuable today, but unfortunately also has been reproduced quite often.
